twitter RSS Feed linkedin acp contact

EAT-Lancet’s recommendations are at odds with sustainable food production

The EAT-Lancet report has recommended changing diets and global food systems

sfp 2Although intensive cattle in some countries are fed on grain, ruminants in many countries predominantly eat grass and arable by-products which humans cannot digest. (Image source: Regina Hart /Flickr)

Due to a fundamental lack of agricultural understanding, some of the main dietary recommendations are incompatible with the food production outcomes of truly sustainable farming systems. For instance, in prioritising reductions in beef and lamb consumption over poultry consumption, the resulting environmental and health outcomes will both be negative.

If fully implemented, the recommendations would make it impossible to introduce sustainable and restorative farming systems in countries like the UK, where a high proportion of farmland is only suitable for growing grass. In addition, grass and grazing animals need to be reintroduced into many all-arable crop rotations to address the serious problems of soil degradation and biodiversity loss.

The failure to make a stronger recommendation in relation to reducing poultry meat consumption is misguided. We recognise that meat consumption overall needs to be reduced, but poultry is in direct competition with humans for grain. Although intensive cattle in some countries are fed on grain, ruminants in many countries predominantly eat grass and arable by-products which humans cannot digest. In relation to the environment, our analysis is that for net greenhouse gas emissions, soil degradation, biodiversity, diffuse agrochemical pollution and human health, reductions need to be made in meat that is largely fed on grain, not meat that is predominantly fed on grass.

Patrick Holden, chief executive of the Sustainable Food Trust (SFT), said, “We welcome the fact that the report highlights the urgent need for fundamental change in farming systems and diets. However, it does little to inform the public about the path to a sustainable future and in some key respects will make things worse.”

Many of the report’s recommendations, such as increased consumption of vegetables, whole grains, nuts and legumes are all sound, but when it comes to protein and fats the recommendations to depend so heavily on plant sources, poultry rather than red meat and unsaturated fats compared with saturated fats are fundamentally flawed. Humans have evolved as red meat eaters and, providing this is part of a balanced diet, beef and lamb provide superior types of protein and fat to plant sources.

Fats make up 36 per cent of daily energy intake in the UK. But rather than getting these from UK grassland via meat and dairy products in an environmentally friendly way as we once did, consumers currently get these from palm oil and soyabean oil, associated as they are with devastating environmental destruction, and from rape and sunflower oil, the production of which have been major causes of pollinator decline due to the high need of these crops for insecticides when grown as monocultures. Over the last decade, a large number of studies in leading peer-reviewed journals, including one in the Lancet itself have challenged the belief that saturated fats are inherently harmful. The fact that this evidence has been completely overlooked by authors suggests that in this area at least, they may be driven more by ideology than a balanced assessment of the evidence.

Many studies have shown that in drought-prone regions of the world, in particular, and areas with poor soil quality, the most important thing is to maintain or build soil organic matter and this can only be achieved sustainably by integrating crop and livestock production and introducing nitrogen by deep-rooting leguminous plants rather than soluble fertiliser.


LATEST NEWS IN Agriculture

USAID and NASA renew partnership to address development and humanitarian challenges

USAID and NASA renew partnership to addr…

On 4 November, Administrator Samantha Power signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) to renew...

Norway promises top-up contribution of urgently needed climate finance

Norway promises top-up contribution of u…

On 9 November 2022, Norway, as part of a commitment to triple its support to climate adaptation by 2026, has pledged an additional US$9.5mn contribution of urgently needed climate finance...

CotonChad and IDH sign partnership with Better Cotton

CotonChad and IDH sign partnership with …

Better Cotton recently signed a multi-stakeholder Letter of Intent to participate in the landscape approach, developed with local stakeholders in Chad in conjunction with IDH, intending to work towards improving...

NFU president Minette Batters appointed as ambassador of Farm Africa

NFU president Minette Batters appointed …

Farm Africa, a charity that promotes sustainable agricultural practices, strengthens markets and protects the environment in rural eastern Africa, has announced the appointment of NFU president Minette Batters as an...

AfDB grants US$63.38mn loan to implement agro-processing project in Senegal

AfDB grants US$63.38mn loan to implement…

The board of directors of the African Development Bank (AfDB) Group in Abidjan has approved a loan of US$63.38mn to Senegal to implement the Agropole-Centre agro-industrial processing zone project

Farming innovations which help conserve nature and create jobs

Farming innovations which help conserve …

On World Food Day, farmers in the UK and globally showed how innovative farming methods and techniques can improve lives, help meet global climate targets and produce food without harming...

Prev Next

OTHER RELATED ARTICLES - Agriculture

South Africa to forge citrus trade links with BRICS partners

South Africa to forge citrus trade links…

The South African government has made a commitment to help the country’s citrus farmers forge trade links with its BRICS partners

Sierra Leone improves food production and cuts imports

Sierra Leone improves food production an…

Sierra Leone has improved its production of rice, cassava and other products according to the country's minister of agriculture, forestry and food security

Olam takes innovative measures to increase cocoa quality and productivity

Olam takes innovative measures to increa…

Pierre Broun, head of plant sciences for Olam Coffee and Cocoa, speaks to African Farming about the company's sustainable measures to help smallholder cocoa farmers in Africa

Common farming practices drain the soil of carbon: Rothamsted Research

Common farming practices drain the soil …

Rothamsted Research scientists have demonstrated that common farming practices drain the soil of carbon, altering the structure of soils’ microscopic habitat and the genetics of microbes living within it

AfDB grants US$11.23mn to Madagascar’s energy, agriculture and pest control

AfDB grants US$11.23mn to Madagascar’s e…

The African Development Bank (AfDB) has signed five project financing agreements with the government of Madagascar worth US$11.23mn

South Africa to target Asian market following maize surplus

South Africa to target Asian market foll…

South Africa, which has had a bumper crop of maize this year leading to depressed prices and dampened demand in Africa, will now target Asian markets to boost maize exports

Kenya's smallholder farmers to get IFAD funding

Kenya's smallholder farmers to get IFAD …

Kenya and the United Nations International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) have signed an agreement to finance smallholder farmers in Kenya

Nigeria approves commercial release of genetically modified cowpea

Nigeria approves commercial release of g…

The Nigerian Biosafety Management Agency (NBMA) has permitted the commercial release of genetically modified cowpea to the farmers

Mozambique to set up special zones for agriculture

Mozambique to set up special zones for a…

The Mozambican government has identified 24 areas where special economic zones (SEZ) for agribusiness can be established

Liberians urged to increase rice and cassava production

Liberians urged to increase rice and cas…

Liberian vice-president Joseph Boakai has urged Liberians to work towards being food sufficient by increasing their rice and cassava production

Shifting to a plant-based diet to significantly help fight climate change: GODAN

Shifting to a plant-based diet to signif…

Andre Laperrière, executive director of Global Open Data for Agriculture and Nutrition (GODAN), has highlighted the impact of Western appetite on global warming and the importance to switching to a...

Zimbabwe considering scrapping fertiliser import duty

Zimbabwe considering scrapping fertilise…

Zimbabwe’s government may remove the import duty on fertilisers this season to help reduce production costs for farmers

Prev Next